Paul Hart Antarctic Explorer With Scott Before the Mast Book Review

With Scott Before the Mast 

Book Review by Paul Hart

 


As a former Royal Navy Officer, who came from the ranks, I was hugely interested in this book and potential insights that it offered from a very different perspective than other books I have read about Scott. 

I am delighted to say that I was not disappointed and actually, the writings of Francis Davies offered not only an insight into Scott and the Terra Nova Expedition, but also the norms and the way that both the navy and society operated. In itself, this combination allows for a detailed consideration of the basis by which the expedition was undertaken and Scott’s leadership was executed. 

As a fellow naval Officer, who has led mixed groups of military and civilians in highly challenging environments and with a background of 30 years of expedition across the globe, I understand the complexities of managing mixed groups where the leadership of the military might necessarily be different to that needed to motivate and manage the civilians. I also understand how the reverse perspective of those being led, can lead to issues when the military contingent expect the civilian contingent to be led according to the same rules of military discipline as they are subject to. In my experience, when these forces combine, discontent and unruliness can commonly be the case unless the leader is able to establish a very high level of trust and respect.

 In doing so, the leader must walk the narrow margin between enforcing group compliance and being able to engage with every person at an individual level. There are many instances in the book where this is presented as a reality of Scott’s leadership, but the book is also very honest about some of his traits that were less desirable and this is essential to understand the man, as well as the expedition itself. The book is well written, with some quite comical observations on the operation of the Royal Navy and on Societal values at the time. It is also littered with a range of interesting photographs that enhance and support visual understanding of the writer’s words. 

As an avid reader of all things Antarctic and a practicing Historian who speaks regularly on Scott and Shackleton, I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone with an interest in such matters. Review by; Lieutenant Commander Paul Hart FRGS MPhil (Cantab) Royal Navy. Leader of the first party to make a man-haul crossing of the Antarctic Peninsula to conduct science and exploration, to commemorate the 100th Anniversary of Captain Robert Falcon Scott reaching the South Pole



Amazon link





















The Terra Nova Journals by 
Francis Davies Leading Shipwright RN


Also Available for Ordering  

The Special Limited Edition, 
Leather Bound, 
Signed and Numbered. 





Amazon link:



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Polar Crean Tom Crean Antarctic Explorer isbn 9781901037197

Image
  Polar Crean  Tom Crean Antarctic Explorer  isbn 9781901037197 Ebay Link https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/255944200732 This is a first edition case bound hardback, which contains a number of  Photographs and maps of Antarctica which appeared with a Tom Crean feature after his death by Dennis Barry.   The rest of the book contains photos showing Discovery just fitted out from the News and Views section in the Black and White Budget Magazine 1901, The exploration of the South Pole. The wonders of the coming Discovery  as part of Anglo-Germanic Expedition by Sir Henry Leach.   Sport in the Antarctic: The games that were played by the Men  of the “Discovery” by Bernard C. Carter and  Animal Life in the Antarctic by S Kemp <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/85105517-
Read more

Big Business Events on buying a golden key to being a millionaire

Image
  Big Business Events OK perhaps not for me, but I was so disappointed and it kept reminding me of the old time share events we all used to attend.   I was sent an invite for a free business event and owning a publishing company this is normal.   What is not so normal is the hidden costs.   Parking in a hotel car park costs £10 for all day!   Did I have to pay? well no I hide the car in the delivery area where the event organizers also hide their cars.   The setting up staff were very rude when I was looking if there was a welcoming drink.   The hotel staff did feel sorry for me and did me a cup of tea.   The meeting was 9am to 5pm and with no drinks or snacks! 8 hours and no offer of refreshment!   If you wanted a biscuit or coffee you had to go out and buy it. Now they did do a snack at lunch time with a special talk with the speakers … But only if you upgraded your ticket from free to VIP at a cost of abou...
Read more

The last days of ernest shackleton on the Quest isbn 9781901037210

Image
 The last days of Ernest Shackleton isbn: 9781901037210 £35 Ebay https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/256112375195 The Last Days of Ernest Shackleton, is a unique and fully illustrated account of Shackleton’s death and burial in South Georgia from the personal point of view of a seaman on the Quest Expedition by the name of George Ross. George joined the Quest Expedition, at a place called Leith Harbour, in South Georgia, with the position donkey-man (a person in charge of a ships engine room) and he explains in detail the daily running of the ship after Shackleton’s death as a first hand account from a below decks crew members point of view. Along with George’s first hand account the book covers both the funeral arrangements, the Shetland Pallbearers, a short history of Shackleton’s Scouts, and the speeches at the unveiling of the Shacketon memorial.  This along with photos, maps, paintings and drawings of the expedition, crew, ship, Grytviken church, funeral and grave. To finish off t...
Read more

The Terra Nova journals by Francis Davies Leading Shipwright RN ..Captain Scotts 1910 to 1913 Antarctic Expedition

Image
  The Terra Nova Journals by  Francis Davies Leading Shipwright RN Covering the 1910 to 1913 Antarctic Expedition I have now turned these journals into a fully illustrated book showing from the crew’s point of view of life below decks. Click Here for Order Details http://www.antarcticbookshop.com/special.htm £175 incl Free UK delivery direct from publishers      Never seen before maps on Antarctica from private collections Top review from the United States Xavier Ninnis 5.0 out of 5 stars   An Embarrassment of Riches! Reviewed in the United States on January 15, 2021 What an unexpected treat, this along with the release of Angie Butler/Beau Riffenburgh’s biography and diaries of Eric Marshall, makes this, for those with an interest (for many, including myself, more an obsession) in Antartica’s "Heroic Age of Exploration," the richest, most exciting period since last decade's spate of releases concerning Mawson’s "Aus...
Read more

Antarctic Books

Image
Antarctic Booklist  BOOK AND CD  Music from Antarctica ISBN: 9781873877524 £14.99 These songs and poems were composed during the Relief Voyage of the British National Antarctic Expedition of 1901-1904. The music was composed by Lieut. G.S. Doorly and the lyrics by Chief Engineer Morrison and other officers, including Ernest Shackleton.  The CD is a result of collaboration by New Zealand musicians and actors to mark the centenary of the voyage of the "Morning" to relieve Captain Scott and company aboard the "Discovery" in 1902. The royalties for this publication are being divided between the Dundee Heritage Trust's Antartic 100 "Discovery" Restoration Fund for work on the restoration of "Discovery", and the New Zealand Antarctic Heritage Trust for preservation work on the expedition's hut and its contents. ISBN: 9781873877524 Polar Crean isbn 9781901037197 £30.00 This is a first edition case bound hardback, which contains a number of Photo...
Read more

Germany in Antarctica During World War 2

Image
  Germany in Antarctica During World War 2 Click below to visit online Order Form for World Wide posting details and prices  www.antarcticbookshop.com/vivant.htm Vivit our online Bookshop www.antarcticbookshop.com On Ebay:  https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/255424939744 This famous book dating from 1947 started off all the stories of Hitler in  Antarctica, you can now own your own copy of this wonderful book  Leading up to the later stories and conspiracy theories of the Americans being attacked by Nazi Wunderwaffe during Operation HighJump.  ISBN 9781901037067      Ebay Link:   Ebay Amazon  link: https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/1901037061/ref=sr_1_3?crid=21AS0M3IWLWXR&keywords=hitler+est+vivant&qid=1643757701&sprefix=hitler+est+%2Caps%2C78&sr=8-3 This wonderful hardback facsimile is of a now rare book published in  Paris ,  France  in 1947 in paperback form and written in French by Ladislas Szabo a Hun...
Read more

First book on Antarctica banned on social media and parts of the USA ! and I published it !

Image
Of all the books I have created on Antarctica over the years I have only had one that I was forced to Bowdlerize and reprint to get around social media censorship including facebook. I was very pleased with my design and translation of the text and sure did not expect the reaction I got. Look the background book cover photo, it is one that I took when in Antarctica ! And yes I am one of the few antarctic Book publishers that has been to Antarctica ! Walmart is a dangerous Organisation ! This is because you previously posted something that didn't follow our Community Standards. This post goes against our standards on dangerous individuals and organisations, so only you and the admins of Antarctica and the South Pole can see it. Antarctic Bookshop Dot Com Antarctica and the South Pole p s t e n S r o d o 4 a f h t 8 a i m l 0 7 6 l h h 1 i g 6 3 l g 2 l a 0 4 c 6 0 2 7 6 2 9 f c 0 4 g 2 8 c 0 0 h 1 7 1    ·  For those that do not believe me when I say shops in the USA c...
Read more

Sea Chest from Shakleton's Endurance Expedition

Image
  An interesting old sea chest that can not be what it says it is. SHIPS PHOTOGRAPHER IMPERIAL TRANS-ANTARCTIC   EXPEDITION  ENDURANCE   A pointless fake or old movie prop? It is like finding luggage from the Titanic, who would believe it to be real?  Its history can be traced back some 70 years where during those years it has resided in  Southampton ,  England . Now it makes a wonderful piece of vintage decorative furniture   A large antique steamer chest.   An English, canvas bound travel trunk with Drawco patent steel, dating to the  Edwardian  period, circa 1910. Generously sized trunk from the golden age of voyages a aged patina Wooden frame with durable black textured fascia Crafted with Drawco steel hoops for a dependable, lightweight trunk The interior finished with a light textile and striking pinstripe pattern This is a generously sized and appealing antique steamer chest, from a golden era of grand tours and so...
Read more

Steve Wroe. BSc (Hons) British Antarctic Survey (1973 to 1975) Before the Mast

Image
  Reviewed By  Steve Wroe Even after all of this time, the name Antarctica still awakens visions of that mysterious place and reminds us of those great explorers from the ‘Heroic age’.  Scott, Shackleton, Amundsen etc. Whilst the stories of these great explorers have been told and retold, this book ‘With Scott Before the Mast’ offers a whole new perspective on Scott’s tragic final expedition. The book offers a viewpoint from this expedition which is unique, as it traces the experiences of Scott’s final expedition from the observations of a member of the crew of the Terra Nova, Francis Davies, Leading Shipwright RN. ISBN 9781901037555   The book is based upon his own journals which trace his experiences in chronological order from his background before applying to join the expedition right through the lifespan of the expedition and the Terra Nova’s return to Cardiff almost one year from setting sail. The language throughout the book is clearly in Davies in his own wor...
Read more